| Year | Champion | Coach | Score | Runner-Up | Score | Host or Site |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2024 | Carnegie Mellon | Dan Rodgers | 1,187 | Emory | 1,201 | Nicholasville, Ky. |
| 2023 | George Fox | Mary Jo McCloskey | 933 | Washington-St. Louis | 938 | Howey-in-the-Hills, Fla. |
| 2022 | Emory | Katie Futcher | 1,175 | Redlands | 1,201 | Houston, Texas |
| 2021 | Methodist | Tom Inczauskis | 1,231 | Carnegie Mellon | 1,236 | East Lansing, Mich. |
| 2020 | Canceled due to Covid-19 | -- | -- | -- | -- | -- |
| 2019 | New York University | Brad Johnson | 1,217 | Williams | 1,222 | Houston, Texas |
| 2018 | Claremont-Mudd-Scripps | Jodie Burton | 1,261 | Williams | 1,261 | Howey-in-the-Hills, Fla. |
| 2017 | Rhodes | Mike Clary | 1,217 | George Fox | 1,219 | Houston, Texas |
| 2016 | Rhodes | Mike Clary | 904 | Texas-Tyler | 919 | Houston, Texas |
| 2015 | Williams | Bill Kangas | 1,264 | Wittenberg | 1,281 | Howey-in-the-Hills, Fla. |
| 2014 | Rhodes | Mike Clary | 1,256 | Mary Hardin-Baylor | 1,280 | Howey-in-the-Hills, Fla. |
| 2013 | Mary Hardin-Baylor | Darla Kirby | 1,239 | Texas-Tyler | 1,247 | Miramar Beach, Fla. |
| 2012 | Methodist | Tom Inczauskis | 1,242 | DePauw | 1,248 | Angola, Ind. |
| 2011 | Methodist | Tom Inczauskis | 966 | Gustavus Adolphus | 978 | Howey-in-the-Hills, Fla. |
| 2010 | Methodist | Tom Inczauskis | 1,282 | Gustavus Adolphus | 1,301 | Howey-in-the-Hills, Fla. |
| 2009 | Methodist | Vici Pate | 1,257 | Wisconsin Stevens Point | 1,282 | Port St. Lucie, Fla. |
| 2008 | Methodist | Vici Pate | 1,219 | DePauw | 1,258 | Wartburg |
| 2007 | Methodist | Vici Pate | 1,215 | DePauw | 1,303 | Howey-in-the-Hills, Fla. |
| 2006 | Methodist | Vici Pate | 1,240 | Gustavus Adolphus | 1,316 | Howey-in-the-Hills, Fla. |
| 2005 | Methodist | Vici Pate | 1,272 | Mary Hardin-Baylor | 1,284 | Southern Pines, N.C. |
| 2004 | Methodist | Vici Pate | 1,303 | Mary Hardin-Baylor | 1,305 | Green Lake, Wis. |
| 2003 | Methodist | Vici Pate | 1,296 | Mary Hardin-Baylor | 1,349 | Green Lake, Wis. |
| 2002 | Methodist | Kim Kincer | 1,310 | Mary Hardin-Baylor | 1,341 | Mount Holyoke |
| 2001 | Methodist | Kim Kincer | 1,214 | Concordia-Moorhead | 1,264 | Millikin |
| 2000 | Methodist | Kim Kincer | 1,285 | Concordia-Moorhead | 1,336 | Illinois Wesleyan |
# 2016 championships shortened to three rounds due to weather.
# 2011 championships shortened to three rounds due to weather.
* From 1996-99, Divisions II and III competed in a combined championship.
