| Year | Champion | Coach | Score | Runner-Up | score | Site |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2025 | Grand Valley State | Jerry Baltes | 60 | Adams State | 59 | Pueblo, Colorado |
| 2024 | Pittsburg State | Kyle Rutledge | 100 | Adams State | 72 | Emporia, KS |
| 2023 | Azusa Pacific | Jack Hoyt | 66 | Minnesota State | 57 | Pueblo, CO |
| 2022 | West Texas A&M | Matt Stewart | 77 | Grand Valley State | 64 | Allendale, MI |
| 2021 | Azusa Pacific | Jack Hoyt | 81 | Grand Valley State | 77 | Allendale, MI |
| 2020 | Canceled by COVID-19 | -- | -- | -- | -- | -- |
| 2019 | Lincoln (Mo.) | Victor Thomas | 64 | Adams State | 54 | Kingsville, TX |
| 2018 | Lincoln (Mo.) | Victor Thomas | 60 | St. Augustine's | 48.5 | Charlotte, N.C. |
| 2017 | West Texas A&M | Darren Flowers | 64 | Grand Valley State | 44 | Bradenton, Fla. |
| 2016 | Pittsburg State | Russ Jewett | 52 | St. Augustine's | 51 | Bradenton, Fla. |
| 2015 | Central Missouri | Kip Janvrin | 59 | Lincoln (Mo.) | 50 | Grand Valley State |
| 2014 | Lincoln (Mo.) | Victor Thomas | 64 | Johnson C. Smith | 59 | Grand Valley State |
| 2013 | Academy of Art | Charles Ryan | 60 | Johnson C. Smith | 54 | Colorado State-Pueblo |
| 2012 | Grand Valley State | Jerry Baltes | 90 | Lincoln (Mo.) | 79 | Colorado State-Pueblo |
| 2011 | Grand Valley State | Jerry Baltes | 82 1/2 | Lincoln (Mo.) | 68 | Cal State-Stanislaus |
| 2010 | Angelo State | James Reid | 87 | Lincoln (Mo.) | 73 | Johnson C. Smith |
| 2009 | Lincoln (Mo.) | Victor Thomas | 85 | Angelo State | 82 | Angelo State |
| 2008 | Abilene Christian | Don D. Hood | 76 1/2 | Adams State | 55 | Cal Poly Pomona |
| 2007 | Lincoln (Mo.) | Victor Thomas | 82 1/2 | Abilene Christian | 82.50 | Johnson C. Smith |
| 2006 | Lincoln (Mo.) | Victor Thomas | 93 | Abilene Christian | 86 | Emporia State |
| 2005 | Lincoln (Mo.) | Victor Thomas | 108 | Cal State Bakersfield | 53 | Abilene Christian |
| 2004 | Lincoln (Mo.) | Victor Thomas | 85 | Adams State | 81 | Cal Poly Pomona |
| 2003 | Lincoln (Mo.) | Victor Thomas | 98 | St. Augustine's | 69 | SIU Edwardsville |
| 2002 | St. Augustine's | George Williams | 54 | North Dakota State | Angelo State | |
| 2001 | St. Augustine's | George Williams | 80 | Western State | SIU Edwardsville | |
| 2000 | St. Augustine's | George Williams | 77 | Abilene Christian | St. Augustine's | |
| 1999 | Abilene Christian | Wes Kittley | 145 1/2 | St. Augustine's | Emporia State | |
| 1998 | Abilene Christian | Wes Kittley | 120 | St. Augustine's | SIU Edwardsville | |
| 1997 | St. Augustine's | George Williams | 81 | Abilene Christian | SIU Edwardsville | |
| 1996 | Abilene Christian | Wes Kittley | 136 | St. Augustine's | UC Riverside | |
| 1995 | Abilene Christian | Wes Kittley | 106 1/2 | *Cal State Los Angeles | Emporia State | |
| 1994 | Abilene Christian | Wes Kittley | 89 1/2 | *Cal State Los Angeles | St. Augustine's | |
| 1993 | Alabama A&M | Joe Henderson | 92 | Abilene Christian | Abilene Christian | |
| 1992 | Alabama A&M | Joe Henderson | 112 | Cal State Los Angeles | Angelo State | |
| 1991 | Cal Poly | Deanne Johnson | 72 | Alabama A&M | Angelo State | |
| 1990 | Cal Poly | Lance Harter | 116 | Norfolk State | Hampton | |
| 1989 | Cal Poly | Lance Harter | 103 | Abilene Christian | Hampton | |
| 1988 | Abilene Christian | Wes Kittley | 109 1/2 | Alabama A&M | Angelo State | |
| 1987 | Abilene Christian | Wes Kittley | 166 | Cal Poly | Southeast Missouri State | |
| 1986 | Abilene Christian | Wes Kittley | 112 | Cal Poly | Cal State Los Angeles | |
| 1985 | Abilene Christian | Wes Kittley | 106 | Cal Poly | Cal State Los Angeles | |
| 1984 | Cal Poly | Lance Harter | 169 1/2 | Alabama A&M | Southeast Missouri State | |
| 1983 | Cal Poly | Lance Harter | 206 | Morgan State | Southeast Missouri State | |
| 1982 | Cal Poly | Lance Harter | 259 | Alabama A&M | Sacramento State |
*Cal State Los Angeles' participation in the 1993-94-95 championships vacated by the krikya18.committee on Infractions. Alabama A&M's participation in the 1994 championships vacated by the krikya18.committee on Infractions.
