| Year | Champion | Coach | Points | Runner-Up | Points | Host or Site |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2024 | Wisconsin-La Crosse | Josh Buchholtz | 74 | Wisconsin-Eau Claire | 52 | Virginia Beach, VA |
| 2023 | Wisconsin-La Crosse | Josh Buchholtz | 35 | MIT | 34.5 | Birmingham, Ala. |
| 2022 | Wisconsin-Eau Claire/Washington U. | Chip Schneider/Jeff Stiles | 35 | Winston-Salem, N.C. | ||
| 2021 | Canceled due to Covid-19 | -- | -- | -- | -- | -- |
| 2020 | Canceled due to Covid-19 | -- | -- | -- | -- | -- |
| 2019 | North Central (Ill.) | Frank Gramarosso | 55 | Mount Union | 39 | Boston |
| 2018 | Mount Union | Kevin Lucas | 41 | North Central (Ill.) | 40 | Birmingham, Ala. |
| 2017 | UW-La Crosse/North Central (Ill.) | Josh Buchholtz/Frank Gramarosso | 34 | North Central | ||
| 2016 | Wisconsin-Eau Claire | Chip Schneider | 53 | Wisconsin-La Crosse | 49 | Grinnell, Iowa |
| 2015 | Wisconsin-Eau Claire | Chip Schneider | 62 | Wisconsin-La Crosse | 60 | Winston-Salem, N.C. |
| 2014 | Wisconsin-La Crosse | Josh Buchholtz | 63.5 | Wisconsin-Eau Claire | 48 | Lincoln, Neb. |
| 2013 | Wisconsin-La Crosse | Josh Buchholtz | 74 | Wisconsin-Oshkosh | 40 | North Central |
| 2012 | North Central (Ill.) | Frank Gramarosso | 48 | Wisconsin-Eau Claire | 37 | Grinnell |
| 2011 | North Central (Ill.) | Frank Gramarosso | 45 | Central College | 44 | Columbus, Ohio |
| 2010 | North Central (Ill.) | Al Carius | 52.3 | Wisconsin-Stevens Point | 34 | DePauw |
| 2009 | UW-La Crosse/UW-Oshkosh | Josh Buchholtz/John Zupanc | 32 | Rose-Hulman | ||
| 2008 | Wisconsin-La Crosse | Don Fritsch | 43 | Monmouth (Ill.) | 33 | Ohio Northern |
| 2007 | Lincoln (Pa.) | Cyrus Jones | 59 | Wisconsin-La Crosse | 48 | Rose-Hulman |
| 2006 | Wisconsin-La Crosse | Mark Guthrie | 78 | Lincoln (Pa.) | 31 | St. Olaf |
| 2005 | Wisconsin-La Crosse | Mark Guthrie | 53 | Lincoln (Pa.) | 38 | Illinois Wesleyan |
| 2004 | Wisconsin-La Crosse | Mark Guthrie | 70 | Wisconsin-Whitewater/Lincoln (Pa.) | 29 | Wisconsin-Whitewater |
| 2003 | Wisconsin-La Crosse | Mark Guthrie | 71 | Wisconsin-Oshkosh | 34 | DePauw |
| 2002 | Wisconsin-La Crosse | Mark Guthrie | 54 | Lincoln (Pa.) | 48 | Ohio Northern |
| 2001 | Wisconsin-La Crosse | Mark Guthrie | 58 | Wisconsin-Oshkosh | 44 | Wisconsin-Oshkosh |
| 2000 | Lincoln (Pa.) | Cyrus Jones | 59 | North Central (Ill.) | 40 | Illinoin Wesleyan |
| 1999 | Lincoln (Pa.) | Cyrus Jones | 60 | Wisconsin-Oshkosh | 37 | Ohio Northern |
| 1998 | Lincoln (Pa.) | Cyrus Jones | 53 | Mount Union | 48 | Brandeis |
| 1997 | Wisconsin-La Crosse | Mark Guthrie | 44 | Lincoln (Pa.) | 41 | Wisconsin-Oshkosh |
| 1996 | Lincoln (Pa.) | Cyrus Jones | 58 | Mount Union | 42 | Smith |
| 1995 | Lincoln (Pa.) | Cyrus Jones | 56 | Albany (N.Y.) | 32 | Ohio Northern |
| 1994 | Wisconsin-La Crosse | Mark Guthrie | 50 | Nebraska Wesleyan | 42 | Wisconsin-Oshkosh |
| 1993 | Wisconsin-La Crosse | Mark Guthrie | 70 | Lincoln (Pa.) | 48 | Bowdoin |
| 1992 | Wisconsin-La Crosse | Mark Guthrie | 57 | Lincoln (Pa.) | 49 | Wisconsin-Stevens Point |
| 1991 | Wisconsin-La Crosse | Mark Guthrie | 58 | Lincoln (Pa.) | 47.5 | Wesleyan (Conn.) |
| 1990 | Lincoln (Pa.) | Cyrus Jones | 36 | MIT | 30.5 | Smith |
| 1989 | North Central (Ill.) | Al Carius | 66.5 | Lincoln (Pa.) | 38 | Bowdoin |
| 1988 | Wisconsin-La Crosse | Mark Guthrie | 36 | St. Lawrence | 30 | Smith |
| 1987 | Wisconsin-La Crosse | Joe Thompson | 44.5 | St. Lawrence | 43 | Chicago |
| 1986 | Frostburg State | Bob Lewis | 38 | Mount Union | 34 | St. Thomas (Minn.) |
| 1985 | St. Thomas (Minn.) | Mark Dienhart | 38 | Lincoln (Pa.) | 34 | Bates |
