| Year | Champion | Coach | Score | Runner-Up | Points | Location |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2024 | Arizona State | Bob Bowman | 523.5 | California | 444.5 | Indianapolis |
| 2023 | California | David Durden | 482 | Arizona State | 430 | Minneapolis, Minn. |
| 2022 | California | David Durden | 487.5 | Texas | 436.5 | Atlanta, GA |
| 2021 | Texas | Eddie Reese | 565 | California | 528 | Greensboro, N.C. |
| 2020 | Canceled due to Covid-19 | -- | -- | -- | -- | -- |
| 2019 | California | David Durden | 560 | Texas | 475 | Austin, Texas |
| 2018 | Texas | Eddie Reese | 449 | California | 437.5 | Minneapolis, Minn. |
| 2017 | Texas | Eddie Reese | 542 | California | 349 | Indianapolis |
| 2016 | Texas | Eddie Reese | 541.5 | California | 351 | Atlanta |
| 2015 | Texas | Eddie Reese | 528 | California | 399 | Iowa City, Iowa |
| 2014 | California | David Durden | 468.5 | Texas | 417.5 | Austin, Texas |
| 2013 | Michigan | Mike Bottom | 480 | California | 406.5 | Indianapolis |
| 2012 | California | David Durden | 535.5 | Texas | 491 | Seattle |
| 2011 | California | David Durden | 493 | Texas | 470.5 | Minneapolis |
| 2010 | Texas | Eddie Reese | 500 | California | 469.5 | Columbus, Ohio |
| 2009 | Auburn | Richard Quick | 526 | Texas | 487 | College Station, Texas |
| 2008 | Arizona | Frank Busch | 500.5 | Texas | 406 | Seattle |
| 2007 | Auburn | David Marsh | 566 | Stanford | 397 | Minneapolis |
| 2006 | Auburn | David Marsh | 480.5 | Arizona | 440.5 | Atlanta |
| 2005 | Auburn | David Marsh | 491 | Stanford | 414 | Minnesota |
| 2004 | Auburn | David Marsh | 634 | Stanford | 377.5 | Long Island, N.Y. |
| 2003 | Auburn | David Marsh | 609.5 | Texas | 413 | Austin, Texas |
| 2002 | Texas | Eddie Reese | 512 | Stanford | 501 | Athens, Texas |
| 2001 | Texas | Eddie Reese | 597.5 | Stanford | 457.5 | College Station, Texas |
| 2000 | Texas | Eddie Reese | 538 | Auburn | 385 | Minneapolis |
| 1999 | Auburn | David Marsh | 467.5 | Stanford | 414.5 | Indianapolis |
| 1998 | Stanford | Skip Kenney | 599 | Auburn | 394.5 | Auburn |
| 1997 | Auburn | David Marsh | 496.5 | Stanford | 340 | Minnesota |
| 1996 | Texas | Eddie Reese | 479 | Auburn | 443.5 | Texas |
| 1995 | Michigan | Jon Urbanchek | 561 | Stanford | 475 | Indianapolis |
| 1994 | Stanford | Skip Kenney | 566.5 | Texas | 445 | Minnesota |
| 1993 | Stanford | Skip Kenney | 520.5 | Michigan | 396 | Indianapolis |
| 1992 | Stanford | Skip Kenney | 632 | Texas | 356 | Indianapolis |
| 1991 | Texas | Eddie Reese | 476 | Stanford | 420 | Texas |
| 1990 | Texas | Eddie Reese | 506 | Southern California | 423 | Indianapolis |
| 1989 | Texas | Eddie Reese | 475 | Stanford | 396 | Indianapolis |
| 1988 | Texas | Eddie Reese | 424 | Southern California | 369.5 | Indianapolis |
| 1987 | Stanford | Skip Kenney | 374 | Southern California | 296 | Texas |
| 1986 | Stanford | Skip Kenney | 404 | California | 335 | Indianapolis |
| 1985 | Stanford | Skip Kenney | 403.5 | Florida | 302 | Texas |
| 1984 | Florida | Randy Reese | 287.5 | Texas | 277 | Cleveland State |
| 1983 | Florida | Randy Reese | 238 | SMU | 227 | Indianapolis |
| 1982 | UCLA | Ron Ballatore | 219 | Texas | 210 | Wisconsin |
| 1981 | Texas | Eddie Reese | 259 | UCLA | 189 | Texas |
| 1980 | California | Nort Thornton | 234 | Texas | 220 | Harvard |
| 1979 | California | Nort Thornton | 287 | Southern California | 227 | Cleveland State |
| 1978 | Tennessee | Ray Bussard | 307 | Auburn | 185 | Long Beach State |
| 1977 | Southern California | Peter Daland | 385 | Alabama | 204 | Cleveland State |
| 1976 | Southern California | Peter Daland | 398 | Tennessee | 237 | Brown |
| 1975 | Southern California | Peter Daland | 344 | Indiana | 274 | Cleveland State |
| 1974 | Southern California | Peter Daland | 339 | Indiana | 338 | Long Beach State |
| 1973 | Indiana | James Counsilman | 358 | Tennessee | 294 | Tennessee |
| 1972 | Indiana | James Counsilman | 390 | Southern California | 371 | Army |
| 1971 | Indiana | James Counsilman | 351 | Southern California | 260 | Iowa State |
| 1970 | Indiana | James Counsilman | 332 | Southern California | 235 | Utah |
| 1969 | Indiana | James Counsilman | 427 | Southern California | 306 | Indiana |
| 1968 | Indiana | James Counsilman | 346 | Yale | 253 | Dartmouth |
| 1967 | Stanford | Jim Gaughran | 275 | Southern California | 260 | Michigan State |
| 1966 | Southern California | Peter Daland | 302 | Indiana | 286 | Air Force |
| 1965 | Southern California | Peter Daland | 285 | Indiana | 278.5 | Iowa State |
| 1964 | Southern California | Peter Daland | 96 | Indiana | 91 | Yale |
| 1963 | Southern California | Peter Daland | 81 | Yale | 77 | North Carolina State |
| 1962 | Ohio State | Mike Peppe | 92 | Southern California | 46 | Ohio State |
| 1961 | Michigan | Gus Stager | 85 | Southern California | 62 | Washington |
| 1960 | Southern California | Peter Daland | 87 | Michigan | 73 | SMU |
| 1959 | Michigan | Gus Stager | 137.5 | Ohio State | 44 | Cornell |
| 1958 | Michigan | Gus Stager | 72 | Yale | 63 | Michigan |
| 1957 | Michigan | Gus Stager | 69 | Yale | 61 | North Carolina |
| 1956 | Ohio State | Mike Peppe | 68 | Yale | 54 | Yale |
| 1955 | Ohio State | Mike Peppe | 90 | Michigan/Yale | 51 | Miami (OH) |
| 1954 | Ohio State | Mike Peppe | 94 | Michigan | 67 | Syracuse |
| 1953 | Yale | Robert J.H. Kiphuth | 96.5 | Ohio State | 73.5 | Ohio State |
| 1952 | Ohio State | Mike Peppe | 94 | Yale | 81 | Princeton |
| 1951 | Yale | Robert J.H. Kiphuth | 81 | Michigan State | 60 | Texas |
| 1950 | Ohio State | Mike Peppe | 65 | Yale | 43 | Ohio State |
| 1949 | Ohio State | Mike Peppe | 49 | Iowa | 35 | North Carolina |
| 1948 | Michigan | Matt Mann | 44 | Ohio State | 41 | Michigan |
| 1947 | Ohio State | Mike Peppe | 66 | Michigan | 39 | Washington |
| 1946 | Ohio State | Mike Peppe | 61 | Michigan | 37 | Yale |
| 1945 | Ohio State | Mike Peppe | 56 | Michigan | 48 | Michigan |
| 1944 | Yale | Robert J.H. Kiphuth | 39 | Michigan | 38 | Yale |
| 1943 | Ohio State | Mike Peppe | 81 | Michigan | 47 | Ohio State |
| 1942 | Yale | Robert J.H. Kiphuth | 71 | Michgan | 39 | Harvard |
| 1941 | Michigan | Matt Mann | 61 | Yale | 58 | Michigan State |
| 1940 | Michigan | Matt Mann | 45 | Yale | 42 | Yale |
| 1939 | Michigan | Matt Mann | 65 | Ohio State | 58 | Michigan |
| 1938 | Michigan | Matt Mann | 46 | Ohio State | 45 | Rutgers |
| 1937 | Michigan | Matt Mann | 75 | Ohio State | 39 | Minnesota |
