| Year | Champion | Coach | Points | Runner-Up | Points | Site |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2023 | Carleton | Donna Ricks | 151 | NYU | 154 | Carlisle, PA |
| 2022 | Johns Hopkins | Bobby Van Allen | 144 | UChicago | 147 | Lansing, Mich. |
| 2021 | Johns Hopkins | Bobby Van Allen | 130 | Claremont-Mudd-Scripps | 132 | Louisville, Ky. |
| 2020 | Canceled due to COVID-19 | -- | -- | -- | -- | -- |
| 2019 | Johns Hopkins | Bobby Van Allen | 125 | Washington-St. Louis | 138 | Louisville, Ky. |
| 2018 | Washington- St. Louis |
Jeff Stiles |
98 | Johns Hopkins | 99 |
Winneconne, Wisc. |
| 2017 | Johns Hopkins | Bobby Van Allen | 96 | Wisconsin-Eau Claire | 191 | Elsah, Ill. |
| 2016 | Johns Hopkins | Bobby Van Allen | 128 | Washington U. | 202 | Louisville, Ky. |
| 2015 | Williams | Peter Farwell | 87 | Geneseo State | 179 | Wisconsin-Oshkosh |
| 2014 | Johns Hopkins | Bobby Van Allen | 87 | MIT | 112 | Wilmington (Ohio) |
| 2013 | Johns Hopkins | Bobby Van Allen | 85 | Williams | 137 | Hanover, Ind. |
| 2012 | Johns Hopkins | Bobby Van Allen | 158 | Wartburg | 221 | Terre Haute, Ind. |
| 2011 | Washington-St. Louis | Jeff Stiles | 70 | Middlebury | 111 | Wisconsin-Oshkosh |
| 2010 | Middlebury | Terry Aldrich | 185 | Washington-St. Louis | 193 | Wartburg |
| 2009 | Wisconsin-Eau Claire | Dan Schwamberger | 171 | St. Lawrence | 180 | Baldwin-Wallace |
| 2008 | Middlebury | Terry Aldrich | 179 | Calvin | 237 | Hanover |
| 2007 | Amherst | Eric Nedeau | 120 | Plattsburgh State | 159 | St. Olaf |
| 2006 | Middlebury | Terry Aldrich | 144 | Amherst | 145 | Wilmington (Ohio) |
| 2005 | SUNY Geneseo | Mike Woods | 88 | Williams | 107 | Ohio Wesleyan |
| 2004 | Williams | Peter Farwell | 110 | Middlebury | 129 | Wisconsin-Eau Claire |
| 2003 | Middlebury | Terry Aldrich | 135 | Trinity (Conn.) | 174 | Hanover |
| 2002 | Williams | Peter Farwell | 42 | Middlebury | 145 | St. Olaf |
| 2001 | Middlebury | Terry Aldrich | 98 | Williams | 166 | Augustana (Ill.) |
| 2000 | Middlebury | Terry Aldrich | 103 | Williams | 123 | Whitworth |
| 1999 | Calvin | Nancy Meyer | 85 | Middlebury | 119 | Wisconsin-Oshkosh |
| 1998 | Calvin | Nancy Meyer | 124 | TCNJ | 170 | Dickinson |
| 1997 | SUNY Cortland | Jack Daniels | 148 | Wisconsin- Eau Claire | 167 | MIT |
| 1996 | Wisconsin-Oshkosh | Deb Vercauteren | 62 | St. Thomas (Minn.) | 113 | Augustana (Ill.) |
| 1995 | SUNY Cortland | Jack Daniels | 46 | Wisconsin-Oshkosh | 83 | Wisconsin-La Crosse |
| 1994 | SUNY Cortland | Jack Daniels | 54 | Calvin | 115 | Moravian |
| 1993 | SUNY Cortland | Jack Daniels | 61 | Calvin | 93 | Grinnell |
| 1992 | SUNY Cortland | Jack Daniels | 18 | Calvin | 108 | Union (N.Y.) |
| 1991 | Wisconsin-Oshkosh | Deb Vercauteren | 98 | SUNY Cortland | 103 | Christopher Newport |
| 1990 | SUNY Cortland | Jack Daniels | 43 | Wisconsin-Oshkosh | 48 | Grinnell |
| 1989 | SUNY Cortland | Jack Daniels | 29 | Wisconsin-Oshkosh | 62 | Augustana (Ill.) |
| 1988 | Wisconsin-Oshkosh | Deb Vercauteren | 69 | St. Thomas (Minn) | 93 | Washington-St. Louis |
| 1987 | St. Thomas (Minn.)/Wisconsin-Oshkosh | Joe Sweeney/Deb Vercauteren | 81 | Hope | ||
| 1986 | St. Thomas (Minn.) | Joe Sweeney | 45 | Ithaca | 73 | Fredonia State |
| 1985 | Franklin & Marshall | Ed Woge | 73 | St. Thomas (Minn.) | 81 | Emory |
| 1984 | St. Thomas (Minn.) | Joe Sweeney | 50 | Wisconsin-La Crosse | 64 | Ohio Wesleyan |
| 1983 | Wisconsin-La Crosse | Gary Wilson | 45 | St. Thomas (Minn.) | 70 | Christopher Newport |
| 1982 | St. Thomas (Minn.) | Joe Sweeney | 44 | Wisconsin-La Crosse | 83 | Fredonia State |
| 1981 | Central (Iowa) | Mike Sullivan | 26 | TCNJ | 70 | Carthage |
