| Year | Champion | Coach | Points | Runner-Up | Points | Host or Site |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2024 | Kenyon | Jess Book | 448 | Denison | 430 | Greensboro, NC |
| 2023 | Denison | Gregg Parini | 464.5 | Emory | 385 | Greensboro, NC |
| 2022 | Kenyon | Jess Book | 446 | Emory | 439 | Indianapolis, IN |
| 2021 | Canceled due to Covid-19 | -- | -- | -- | -- | -- |
| 2020 | Canceled due to Covid-19 | -- | -- | -- | -- | -- |
| 2019 | Emory | Jon Howell | 488 | Kenyon | 479 | Greensboro, NC |
| 2018 | Emory | Jon Howell | 603 | Kenyon | 500 | Indianapolis, Indiana |
| 2017 | Emory | Jon Howell | 645.5 | Williams | 445 | Shenandoah, Texas |
| 2016 | Emory | Jon Howell | 560 | Kenyon | 476 | Greensboro, NC |
| 2015 | Emory | Jon Howell | 603 | Denison | 457.5 | Shenandoah, Texas |
| 2014 | Emory | Jon Howell | 595.5 | Kenyon | 456.5 | Indianapolis |
| 2013 | Emory | Jon Howell | 619 | Kenyon | 483 | Shenandoah, Texas |
| 2012 | Emory | Jon Howell | 639 | Williams | 453 | Indianapolis |
| 2011 | Emory | Jon Howell | 614 | Denison | 428 | Knoxville, Tenn. |
| 2010 | Emory | Jon Howell | 568.5 | Denison | 452 | Minneapolis |
| 2009 | Kenyon | Jim Steen | 560 | Emory | 466.5 | Minneapolis |
| 2008 | Kenyon | Jim Steen | 566.5 | Amherst | 341 | Wooster |
| 2007 | Kenyon | Jim Steen | 538 | Amherst | 320 | Houston |
| 2006 | Emory | Jon Howell | 428 | Kenyon | 418 | Carleton |
| 2005 | Emory | Jon Howell | 399.5 | Kenyon | 313 | Hope |
| 2004 | Kenyon | Jim Steen | 507 | Emory | 362 | Principia |
| 2003 | Kenyon | Jim Steen | 560.5 | Williams | 350 | Emory |
| 2002 | Kenyon | Peter Casares | 577 | Denison | 418 | Miami (Ohio) |
| 2001 | Denison | Gree Parini | 588 | Kenyon | 572 | Buffalo |
| 2000 | Kenyon | Jim Steen | 619.5 | Denison | 417.5 | Emory |
| 1999 | Kenyon | Jim Steen | 664.5 | Denison | 503 | Oxford, Ohio |
| 1998 | Kenyon | Jim Steen | 693.5 | Denison | 522 | St. Louis |
| 1997 | Kenyon | Jim Steen | 572 | Williams | 377 | Oxford, Ohio |
| 1996 | Kenyon | Jon Howell | 542 | UC San Diego | 380 | Emory |
| 1995 | Kenyon | Jim Steen | 527.5 | Williams | 333 | Wesleyan (Conn.) |
| 1994 | Kenyon | Jim Steen | 595.5 | Hope | 408.5 | Williams |
| 1993 | Kenyon | Jim Steen | 683 | UC San Diego | 451.5 | Emory |
| 1992 | Kenyon | Jim Steen | 750 | UC San Diego | 408 | Buffalo |
| 1991 | Kenyon | Jim Steen | 661.5 | UC San Diego | 466 | Emory |
| 1990 | Kenyon | Jim Steen | 506 | UC San Diego | 443 | Williams |
| 1989 | Kenyon | Jim Steen | 631 | UC San Diego | 298.5 | Notre Dame |
| 1988 | Kenyon | Jim Steen | 581.5 | UC San Diego | 338.5 | Emory |
| 1987 | Kenyon | Jim Steen | 659 | Pomona-Pitzer | 349.5 | Canton, Ohio |
| 1986 | Kenyon | Jim Steen | 713 | UC San Diego | 403.5 | Canton, Ohio |
| 1985 | Kenyon | Jim Steen | 496 | Pomona-Pitzer | 348 | Emory |
| 1984 | Kenyon | Jim Steen | 307.5 | Hamline | 283.5 | Emory |
| 1983 | Williams | Carl Samuelson | 330.5 | Hamline | 286 | Canton, Ohio |
| 1982 | Williams | Carl Samuelson | 402 | Kenyon | 303 | Massachusetts-Boston |
