Championship History

  Year Champion Coach Points Runner-Up Points Host or Site
  2023 Pomona-Pitzer Amber Williams 158 Wisconsin-La Crosse 159 Carlisle, PA
  2022 MIT Riley Macon 82 Wartburg 129 Lansing, Mich. 
  2021 Pomona-Pitzer Kyle Flores 80 MIT 112 Louisville, Ky.
  2020 Canceled due to COVID-19 -- -- -- -- --
  2019 Pomona-Pitzer Jordan Carpenter 164 North Central (Ill.) 182 Louisville, Ky.
  2018 North Central (Ill.) Al Carius 43 Washington U.  110

Winneconne, Wisc.
  2017 North Central (Ill.) Al Carius 57 Wisconsin-La Crosse 196 Elsah, Ill.
  2016 North Central (Ill.)  Al Carius 60 SUNY Geneseo 204 Louisville, Ky.
  2015 Wisconsin-Eau Claire Dan Schwamberger 135 Williams 144 Winneconne, Wis.
  2014 North Central (Ill.) Al Carius 130 St. Olaf 143 Wilmington (Ohio)
  2013 St. Olaf Phil Lundin 84 North Central (Ill.) 86 Hanover, Ind.
  2012 North Central (Ill.) Al Carius 167 Calvin and Haverford* 188 Terre Haute, Ind.
  2011 North Central (Ill.) Allen Carius 110 Haverford 172 Wisconsin-Oshkosh
  2010 Haverford Tom Donnelly 87 North Central (Ill.) 104 Wartburg
  2009 North Central (Ill.) Allen Carius 50 Williams 181 Baldwin-Walace
  2008 SUNY Cortland Steve Patrick 80   115 Hanover
  2007 New York University Nicholas McDonough 128 Haverford 150 St. Olaf
  2006 Calvin Brian Diemer 37 New York University 92 Wilmington (Ohio)
  2005 Wisconsin-La Crosse Don Fritsch 94 Calvin 117 Ohio Wesleyan
  2004 Calvin Brian Diemer 107 North Central (Ill.) 137 Wisconsin-Eau Claire
  2003 Calvin Brian Diemer 48 Wisconsin-Stevens Point 128 Hanover
  2002 Wisconsin-Oshkosh John Zupanc 66 Calvin 122 St. Olaf
  2001 Wisconsin-La Crosse Don Fritsch 80 Calvin 140 Augustana (Ill.)
  2000 Calvin Brian Diemer 65 Keene State 87 Whitworth
  1999 North Central (Ill.) Allen Carius 84 Keene State 100 Wisconsin-Oshkosh
  1998 North Central (Ill.) Allen Carius 106 Calvin 122 Dickinson
  1997 North Central (Ill.) Allen Carius 94 Mount Union 96 MIT
  1996 Wisconsin-La Crosse Phil Esten 86 North Central (Ill.) 94 Augustana (Ill.)
  1995 Williams Peter Farwell 83 North Central (Ill.) 91 Wisconsin-La Crosse
  1994 Williams Peter Farwell 98 North Central (Ill.) 110 Moravian
  1993 North Central (Ill.) Allen Carius 32 Wisconsin-La Cross 123 Grinnell
  1992 North Central (Ill.) Allen Carius 107 Rochester (N.Y.) 114 Union (N.Y.)
  1991 Rochester (N.Y.) Tim Hale 139 North Central (Ill.) 147 Christopher Newport
  1990 Wisconsin-Oshkosh John Zupanc 87 North Central (Ill.) 100 Grinnell
  1989 Wisconsin-Oshkosh John Zupanc 55 North Central (Ill.) 118 Augustana (Ill.)
  1988 Wisconsin-Oshkosh John Zupanc 66 North Central (Ill.) 75 Washington-St. Louis
  1987 North Central (Ill.) Allen Carius 67 Wisconsin-La Cross 78 Hope
  1986 St. Thomas (Minn.) Larry Russ 51 Wisconsin-La Cross 72 Fredonia State
  1985 Luther Kent Finanger 98 North Central (Ill.) 150 Emory
  1984 St. Thomas (Minn.) Larry Russ 76 North Central (Ill.) 89 Ohio Wesleyan
  1983 Brandeis Norman Levine 52 North Central (Ill.) 89 Christopher Newport
  1982 North Central (Ill.) Allen Carius 51 Brandeis 89 Fredonia State
  1981 North Central (Ill.) Allen Carius 89 Brandeis 107 Carthage
  1980 Carleton Bill Huych 121 Augustana (Ill.) 125 Rochester (N.Y.)
  1979 North Central (Ill.) Glen Behnke/Allen Carius 85 Humboldt State 93 Augustana (Ill.)
  1978 North Central (Ill.) Glen Behnke/Allen Carius 60 Luther 151 Augustana (Ill.)
  1977 Occidental Steve Haas 149 Humboldt State 152 Case
  1976 North Central (Ill.) Allen Carius 109 Humboldt State 132 Case
  1975 North Central (Ill.) Allen Carius 91 Occidental 111 Brandeis
  1974 Mount Union Jim Wuske 105 Occidental 148 Wheaton (Ill.)
  1973 Ashland Paul Armor 66 Albany (N.Y.)/North Central (Ill.) 172 Wheaton (Ill.)

* Denotes a tie for second place.